Steel garage doors typically cost $250–$4,000. Wood ranges from $1,000–$8,000+. Steel is cheaper upfront and needs less upkeep. Wood offers unmatched curb appeal, customization, and resale value. The best option depends on your budget, design goals, and how you use your garage.
You’re not alone if you’re weighing the cost of a wood garage door versus metal and wondering if the aesthetic and value of wood justifies the investment.
The short answer? Steel doors are more affordable and practical for many homeowners, but handcrafted wood doors deliver something mass-produced metal can’t: a timeless, architectural impact that elevates the entire home.
At Image Doors, we’ve built our reputation around one thing, craftsmanship that stands the test of time.
Our solid wood carriage-style garage doors are handcrafted one at a time using premium materials like Clear Western Red Cedar and reclaimed barnwood, giving every project a one-of-a-kind finish.
For those who need the durability of steel but crave the warmth of wood, our steel-core composite doors with wood overlays blend performance and beauty.
If you want a quick, functional breakdown, keep reading. Let’s walk through the real cost, design, and decision points together.
Quick Price Breakdown (No Fluff, Just the Numbers)
When it comes to price, steel garage doors win on initial cost, but that’s only part of the story.
- Steel: $250 – $4,000
- Wood: $1,000 – $8,000+ (handcrafted, stain-grade, or reclaimed wood can push this higher)
- Faux Wood/Composite: $1,000 – $5,000
- Installation: $500 – $1,800 additional for either material
- Customization: Increases cost regardless of material, but more so with wood due to artisan labor
Which is cheaper, a steel or wood garage door? Steel, by hundreds or even thousands. But price tags alone don’t account for design integrity, resale value, or lifetime satisfaction.
Upfront vs Long-Term Costs, What You’re Actually Paying For
Featured Product: Custom Painted Wood Carriage House Garage Doors
While steel is easier on your wallet at the outset, wood can pay off in curb appeal, resale value, and emotional satisfaction.
- Steel offers immediate savings in both purchase and installation.
- Wood is an investment in home character, especially in high-end neighborhoods where architectural detail matters.
- Our wood garage doors consistently deliver 1–4% increased home resale value, based on client sales feedback and real estate reports.
- Fire-resistant steel may qualify for insurance discounts, especially in wildfire-prone areas.
Will a wood garage door pay off at resale? Yes, some of our clients have seen a near 98% ROI. That’s higher than most kitchen or bathroom remodels.
Maintenance & Durability: Time and Effort in the Real World
Let’s address a common worry: upkeep. The myth? Wood doors are a maintenance nightmare. The truth? Not if they’re made right.
- Steel requires less maintenance, but it’s prone to rust and denting, especially in coastal or high-impact areas.
- Wood, when properly sealed and maintained, holds strong for 15–20 years. Many of our clients go longer with routine care.
- Our go-to material, Cedar, resists rot and pests. Sapele offers a dense, elegant finish.
- Our handcrafted doors are built one at a time, then inspected and sanded by hand, making them last longer than mass-produced alternatives.
Do wood garage doors require too much upkeep? Only if neglected. Modern finishes drastically cut down on maintenance.
Will steel rust or dent too easily? Yes, unless you opt for galvanized or powder-coated options. Even then, dents from cars or kids can be hard to hide.
Insulation & Energy Efficiency: Which Keeps Your Garage Comfortable?
Featured Product: Custom Steel Carriage House Garage Doors
Whether your garage is a storage room or a workspace, temperature matters.
- Steel doors with polyurethane insulation offer top-tier R-values, ideal for energy-conscious households.
- Wood is naturally insulating thanks to its density, but it’s less efficient than high-end insulated steel.
Both wood and steel doors from Image Doors can be ordered with insulated cores for improved thermal performance.
Which is better for insulation, wood or steel? Steel, if you’re using a triple-layer insulated model. For natural insulation with warmth and charm, wood still holds its own.
Curb Appeal and Customization: Looks That Sell
It either complements the overall design… or compromises it.
- Wood offers true customization, grain, stain, paneling, decorative hardware, even reclaimed materials. No two are the same.
- Steel doors can mimic wood with faux finishes or overlays, but they don’t deliver the same texture or depth.
- Hardware matters: hand-forged hinges, ring pulls, and handle sets complete the story of your home.
At Image Doors, we design custom doors that match historic blueprints, luxury estates, or any personal vision you bring.
Are wooden garage doors worth it? Absolutely, if you’re investing in a door that enhances home character and resale appeal.
Common Mistakes & Buying Regrets (From Real Customers)
We’ve heard the stories, buyers who went with the cheaper, mass-produced option and called us later with a hint of regret.
- Choosing cost over compatibility: A sleek steel door on a craftsman home can feel out of place.
- Skipping insulation for attached garages, then paying for it in heating bills.
- Expecting faux wood to match the character of solid cedar or reclaimed timber, it doesn’t.
- Underestimating long-term maintenance: Not in workload, but in cost of appearance and hardware failure.
Will I regret buying a cheaper steel door? If curb appeal and longevity matter, you might. Our customers often say they wish they had upgraded sooner.
Real-Life Use Cases: Which Door Fits Your Lifestyle?
Featured Product: Custom Painted Wood Carriage House Garage Doors
Your garage isn’t just a place for cars anymore. It might be a workshop, studio, or home gym. The right door depends on how you live.
- Attached Garage: Prioritize insulation. Both materials work, steel is cost-effective, wood feels warmer.
- Luxury Home: Nothing beats a custom wood carriage door for elegance and resale leverage.
- Budget-Conscious Buyer: Steel or composite gets the job done, with a clean, low-maintenance look.
- Coastal Properties: Galvanized steel resists corrosion. Cedar resists rot and insects naturally.
- Detached Garage or Studio: Consider the weight and soundproofing of a dense wood door.
Final Verdict: Wood vs Steel
There’s no wrong answer, just the one that fits your needs.
Choose Steel If:
- You’re on a tighter budget
- You want minimal maintenance
- You’re prioritizing insulation and function
Choose Wood If:
- You’re enhancing curb appeal or restoring a historic property
- You value craftsmanship and uniqueness
- You want the emotional and visual impact of a one-of-a-kind entrance
What’s the least expensive material for a garage door? Basic single-layer steel is your most cost-efficient option.
When a Garage Door Becomes a Statement
Choosing between wood and metal isn’t just a financial decision, it’s about what kind of home you’re building, and what kind of presence you want to create.
- Steel offers simplicity, efficiency, and lower upfront cost. It’s a strong fit for functional spaces and budget-driven upgrades.
- Wood offers soul. It brings warmth, depth, and detail that factory-finished panels can’t replicate. It’s about honoring the character of your home, and adding to its story.
- Hybrid options (like steel with wood overlays) are perfect if you want the strength of metal with the charm of wood.
At Image Doors:
- We use premium species like Cedar and Sapele for beauty that lasts.
- We hand-fit every panel and custom-forge hardware to match the architecture of your home.
- We design each door not just for function, but for feeling.
If you’re deciding between cost and character, contact us today. We’re ready to help you.
Recent Comments